Back to Squawk list
  • 11

The New “Sully” Movie: How Accurate?

提交時間:
 
Airbus A320 Captain and Noted Aviation Author, Eric Auxier aka "Cap'n Aux", opines on the accuracy of the upcoming movie starring Tom Hanks about "The Miracle on the Hudson". Did Hollywood get it right? What can be gathered from just the trailers.... (airwaysmag.com) 更多...

Sort type: [Top] [Newest]


ColinSeftel
Any movie directed by Clint Eastwood will be worth seeing.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

LoralThomas
Sully and crew did a fantastic job on the Hudson. Just wish he had kept his mouth closed about the 1,500 hr. rule! His presence in Washington changed the hour requirements for new pilots trying to get into Part 121 or 135 and all because the family of those tragically killed in the Colgan crash demanded action. He was a very visible target and Washington and the FAA used him to their best interest.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

royhunte92
Roy Hunte 2
Yes Peter, that is correct, but apparently on Cactus 1549, the button was never pressed and on post aircraft recovery, inspection showed that the water impact ruptured th fuselage, so the button probably would not have made a difference.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

ToddBaldwin3
Are you, by any chance, an attorney?
royhunte92
Roy Hunte 3
Was wondering the same, Todd.
joelwiley
joel wiley 1
It is a matter of public record:
http://members.calbar.ca.gov/fal/MemberSearch/QuickSearch?FreeText=peter+f+hartmann&SoundsLike=false&x=51&y=10
ToddBaldwin3
Thank you Joel. I guess I could have researched that myself. That explains a lot.
tyketto
Umm... you do know that Sullenberger was PIC when the landing happened, correct?

BL.
30west
30west 2
Brad,

I think you're interchanging the titles Captain, PIC, Pilot Flying, First Officer, SIC, Pilot Not Flying.

Sully was the Captain (in airline terms) and the PIC from the moment he signed in for the flight assignment that included that particular flight. Skiles was the F/O and SIC for the same period. Who was flying the jet did not have any impact on these titles and the responsibilities that come with them.

During the various legs of that trip, they exchanged roles of "Pilot Flying" and "Pilot Not Flying" (or "Pilot Monitoring" which some use). I read Sully flew the leg from CLT-LGA which makes sense since Skiles was flying the accident leg. Those roles have no bearing on who is the Captain & PIC or F/O & SIC, that doesn't change based upon who has his hands on the controls flying the jet. However, the duties of PF and PNF switch between the two based upon who is actually flying the jet.

On the accident leg, the F/O (SIC) was the Pilot Flying until the proverbial sh!t hit the fan and then the Captain took control of the jet and became the PF. That changeover of these duties had no effect on the fact that Sully was the Captain/PIC of this flight for the entire period of time.
dee9bee
dee9bee 1
I read the previous to mean that Skiles, the First Officer, was the man giving the speech to his group, as opposed to Sully.
tyketto
Understood, but Peter's comment, like the one above and the other one above that, implies that Skiles was PIC after the birdstrike and subsequent ditching into the Hudson; as we all know, especially from that particular squawk here, that isn't true.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

tyketto
You saying that Skiles "likes water landings" implies that he would have preferred the Hudson to landing at any other suitable airport, which wasn't an option. As Sully had the aircraft, it was his best judgment and decision, which lead to what took place.

How about working more on your choice of words so there won't be any misunderstandings of what you mean.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

tyketto
Yeah. That's why us "fliers" have their PPLs, with some being CFIs, and others being ATC.

Nah.. We have nothing to do with real world aviation at all...

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

royhunte92
Roy Hunte 1
That was a comment made on the documentary, Crash on the Hudson, What really happened. Haven't actually confirmed, sorry. Please notice I said 'apparently'.

登入

還沒有帳戶嗎? 現在就註冊(免費),設置諸多客制化功能、航班提醒等等!
您知道FlightAware航班跟蹤是由廣告支持嗎?
通過允許展示來自FlightAware.com的廣告,您可以幫助我們使FlightAware保持免費。我們努力使我們的廣告保持相關性,同時不顯突兀,以創造一流的體驗。在FlightAware上將廣告加入白名單快速而簡單,或者請您考慮選擇我們的高級帳戶.
退出